In AEC M&A, the headline price is only half the story. How a deal is structured determines how much of that price a seller actually keeps, how much risk a buyer takes on, and how smoothly the firm changes hands. Whether you are buying or selling, these are the structures and norms to understand before a Letter of Intent is signed.
Asset Purchase vs. Stock Purchase
Every external sale starts with one basic choice: is the buyer purchasing the legal entity, or the assets inside it?
|
|
Stock purchase |
Asset purchase |
|
What is sold |
The legal entity itself |
The assets, plus AP and other assumed liabilities, moved into the buyer's entity |
|
Contracts |
No client consents needed unless a contract has a change-of-control clause |
Assigned to the new entity, with client consent required |
|
Employees and bank accounts |
Stay in place, with little transition work |
Employees transfer and new bank accounts are opened |
|
Liability |
Buyer inherits the entity's history, so it needs more diligence and indemnification |
Buyer avoids known and unknown liabilities from before closing |
|
Tax advantage |
Usually favors the seller through favorable long-term capital gains rates. |
Usually favors the buyer, through a step-up in basis on the purchased assets. |
Stock deals are simpler and typically better for the seller's taxes, while asset deals protect the buyer and give it better tax treatment.
Two Tax-Driven Hybrids
Two increasingly common structures aim to give the buyer an asset deal's tax benefits while keeping much of a stock deal's simplicity: 338(h)(10) election. Both parties sign an IRS election that treats a stock sale as an asset sale for tax purposes. The deal keeps the simplicity of a stock purchase, with no contract consents or employee transfers, and gives the buyer an asset deal's tax benefit. The tradeoff is a less favorable result for the seller.
- F-reorganization. A series of legal entity changes before closing gives the buyer a step-up in basis, at a higher tax cost to the seller. F-reorgs are gaining popularity because they produce the best overall tax outcome for buyer and seller combined. Many AEC firms in desirable markets and geographies are in a seller's market and can negotiate a tax true-up payment, in which the buyer covers the seller's added tax cost.
- Seller note. Paid out over two to three years.
- Earnout. Post-closing payments contingent on future performance, measured by profit, revenue or headcount retention. Earnouts often bridge a valuation gap or account for a recent dip in profits, but they are difficult to structure and measure, and they can delay integration.
- Rolled equity. The seller retains an ownership stake, a defining feature of private equity recapitalizations and, increasingly, in acquisitions by employee-owned firms as well.
- Stay periods. Negotiable, but buyers generally look for selling owners to stay three years, followed by a two-year non-compete and non-solicit.
- Tail insurance. Professional liability coverage for work performed before closing. It is typically the seller's obligation, though the cost is often split.
- Escrow holdbacks. Usually 5% to 10% of the price, held for about 18 months to cover indemnification, plus a separate holdback of roughly three months for closing statement adjustments. Representations and warranties insurance is beginning to appear in AEC deals.
Because structure changes the tax bill, two offers with the same headline price can leave a seller with very different net proceeds. A team that includes an M&A advisor, Tax Advisor, and an M&A attorney with deep M&A tax experience is essential to evaluate them.
How Sellers Get Paid
Most AEC deals pay 60% to 90% of the price in cash at closing. The balance is deferred through one or more of the following.
- Seller note. Paid out over two to three years.
- Earnout. Post-closing payments contingent on future performance, measured by profit, revenue or headcount retention. Earnouts often bridge a valuation gap or account for a recent dip in profits, but they are difficult to structure and measure, and they can delay integration.
- Rolled equity. The seller retains an ownership stake, a defining feature of private equity recapitalizations and, increasingly, in acquisitions by employee-owned firms as well.
Commitments and Protections After Closing
- Stay periods. Negotiable, but buyers generally look for selling owners to stay three years, followed by a two-year non-compete and non-solicit.
- Tail insurance. Professional liability coverage for work performed before closing. It is typically the seller's obligation, though the cost is often split.
- Escrow holdbacks. Usually 5% to 10% of the price, held for about 18 months to cover indemnification, plus a separate holdback of roughly three months for closing statement adjustments. Representations and warranties insurance is beginning to appear in AEC deals.
Cash-Free, Debt-Free and Working Capital
Most deals are priced cash-free and debt-free. The seller keeps the cash on hand at closing and pays off debt, other than AP and any negotiated assumed liabilities. Accrued vacation counts as a debt owed to employees, and it is most commonly transferred to the buyer with a matching credit against the price.
Working capital is where many M&A conversations run into friction. The buyer expects the firm to deliver a normal level of net working capital at closing: receivables, retention, WIP and prepaid expenses, minus payables, retention payables, billings in excess and customer deposits. The target is usually set at the trailing 12-month average, and any shortfall or excess is settled dollar for dollar.
Why do receivables stay with the business? Because the buyer is paying for cash flow, and market valuations already include receivables as part of any accrual-based EBITDA calculation. Taking them out would be “double-dipping” those amounts.
The Bottom Line
Buyers and sellers alike should put critical terms on the table early and document them in the LOI, especially any request that falls outside the norm. And when comparing offers, particularly a stock deal against an asset deal, judge them by net after-tax proceeds, not headline price. These structures are just the beginning, however, and the terms underneath them control value and outcomes across dozens of concepts and terms. Karl Wohler, M&A Advisor for PSMJ, will present the latest deal trends, and valuation structures, as well as review the Private Equity option for AEC firm owners on December 8, 2026. You can register to attend here.
Curious to learn more? Leverage PSMJ’s 52 years of success in helping ownership teams achieve their goals, whether it’s to define your business strategy, execute an M&A transaction with professional transaction advisors, or establish a succession plan to ensure the firm survives independently for the long term, PSMJ is ready to help your firm achieve more. Click here to start that conversation.
This article is intended for informational purposes and does not constitute legal, financial, or investment advice. Firms considering intellectual property strategy or M&A transactions should consult qualified legal advisors.
